Fixing the SID of a copied virtual machine
"The name or security ID (SID) of the domain specified is inconsistent with
the trust information for that domain"
After a bit of digging on google, I found that its an issue with one or more servers on the same domain using the same SID. Since both my servers in this case were copies of the same base windows 2003 server, I was running into exactly that issue. I was able to fix the problem by changing the SID of my new server using the NewSID tool.